@6928849
@6928836
@5695427
@6943100

@6916724

@6917153

reporting map: @4051197 alignment

@6931570

@6939253 , @6938837 , @6937922 , @6937627 , @6866003 , @6865943 ,

Reporting Map: @1697574
Reason: hidden roof

reporting map:@442098
cheese part soloable

@6944696

@6883742

@6946947

Reporting Map: @1999534
Reason: Unaligned

@6950054

checkpoint

Reporting map: @1697574
Reason: hidden roof

reporting map:
@4051197 - alignment
@3049560 - offscreen shortcut http://imgur.com/a/ZsZCV
@1492702 - wjable wall; ta possible
@1937289 - hidden roof
@2136058 - offscreen shortcut (wj)
@6970905 - offscreen advantage (offscreen route is easier) http://imgur.com/a/Yzkpt

@4372222 - edited

Reviews for maps submitted in October 2016

Accepted
@6643104 - Kimsterjay - Difficulty 4
@6834168 - Kimsterjay - Difficulty 2
@6888926 - Gekkeiju - Difficulty 7
@6892496 - Gekkeiju - Difficulty 7
@6894779 - Gekkeiju - Difficulty 7
@6894763 - Gekkeiju - Difficulty 6
@6894757 - Gekkeiju - Difficulty 6
@6907209 - Amelizz - Difficulty 6


Almost Accepted

@6881082 - Yinjackson - Difficulty 6

• water should be behind ice. (in order to make the map look nicer)
• cheese and hole must be placed like this http://i.imgur.com/YSsJmKp.png (in order to make the map focused on its main concept of building a foundation. In the current design, making a slope back to the hole in the water is frustrating for shaman and mice's skills to climb up on a slope in water can affect the result.)

@6901527 - Yinjackson - Difficulty 7

• design of the anticloud can be improved. at least the author should remove the parts show in http://imgur.com/tCbKZiI they are unnecessary obstacles when making a bridge which is irrelevant to the main concept of this map.

@6897589 - Gekkeiju - Difficulty 7

• This map can be shorter maintaining its concept.

@6887608 - Amelizz - Difficulty 5

• Small misalignments
• wind too strong (the resultant force of wind and gravity should have the same angle as the major grounds in the map)

@6905112 - Kimsterjay - Difficulty 6

• gravity must be the extent mice can go up on a 45 degree slope with cheese. (because the major grounds are at an angle of 45 degree)

@3731755 - Mastaoftime - Difficulty 7

• design can be improved

@6908584 - Elen1020 - Difficulty 6

• cheese and hole too high making the map look awkward and uncomfortable. they can be 30~50 px lower.

@6914271 - Alisaakkaia - Difficulty 4

• small misalignment

Rejected

@6893602 - Yinjackson
stably solvable with only 1 cannon and 5 times portal spawns. Anticlouds must not be expressed as hollowed grounds in a portal map because whether the hollowed areas have collision with mice or not is not formally defined. (it's not a problem in non-portal maps because mice can never go there.)
ice + water makes builds harder and unstabler. the center ground can be another type of ground which has friction.

@6901523 - Yinjackson
shaman gets stuck after he jumps. the circles should be cloud. they are too much obstacle making the map more monosolution. anti-gravity does not give an interesting concept about structure in solutions but it restricts solutions excessively by disabling mice from jumping. a green anchor must be at (0,0) instead of the red square.
hole too far. as shown in the picture http://i.imgur.com/PjuAplC.png and http://i.imgur.com/M9pePgZ.png it's highly expected that shaman makes a slope to the cheese which seemingly can't reach it. although it actually works due to the weak gravity, it should be more obvious that the slope is safe enough for mice.

@6881784 - Slipprs
P44 maps are not accepted. additonaly cannon solu works and this map cannot be no-balloon since balloons work effectively in the antigravity version of this map.

@6899717 - Slipprs
P44 maps are not accepted. additionally, the space between skulls allow mice to pass through. anticloud walls are needed on both sides to prevent offscreen death. encouraging offscreen gameplay. (http://imgur.com/a/23Wz5 http://i.imgur.com/EutvvQO.png)

@6857969 - Fuzzyfirsdog
this map was resubmitted before the last month's review, where this map was being discussed, hadn't finished.

@6892590 - Gekkeiju
visually unapealing. uncomfortable to build on.

@6913859 - Amelizz
excessive decoration. misalignments in decoration http://i.imgur.com/z547tMZ.png

@6895891 - Amelizz
generic (ex. @4276657 @1922800 @168872 @2720765 @2800239) random coordinates of the cage grounds. cage too cramped. solutions using boxes in the cage look ugly although they work well.

@6890001 - Amelizz
generic concept for it's difficulty (ex @3067847 @2639154 @2890815 @2973513). misalignments (not perfectly symmetric). visually unapealing since the center ground is very dark compared to the other 4 side grounds. the tiny ground is not necessary if shaman and mice start at the hole.

@6909060 - Amelizz
fake friction. random x coordinates. penetration foundation overpowered http://i.imgur.com/N7JndUD.png
the walls are almost offscreen.

@6909541 - Amelizz
random x coordinates. generic for its difficulty (ex. @509320 @273581 @2973874 @1743871 @6693861)
the objects appearing at the beginning should be put above the cloud because the cloud has a special collision too.

@6911915 - Amelizz
this map could be interesting if shaman couldn't attach balloons to objects crossing the center cloud then shaman would need to build a foundation on the triangle platform. however, since shaman can tie balloons around the cloud in the current design, this map can be solved in the same way as @476169 is solved.
since offscreen building (ex. http://i.imgur.com/rVIHyDa.png) is highly expected, the platform should be lower or Ca="" should be added into the P tag to hide offscreen.
little misalignment (x coordinates of the lower right platform should be 656)

@6909934 - Amelizz
cannon solutions works if the mice are pro enough cooperative. (too much depending on mice's skill)

@6913717 - Amelizz
small misalignments. similar to @3524657 which is already in the rotation.

@3524460 - Idlenovice
cheese is soloable. http://i.imgur.com/TJJifLs.png

@6903516 - Rainyia
little misalignments. hole looks soloable (it's actually soloable. ice must be long enough that it's not soloable and it doesn't look soloable to prevent mice from trying to solo). a little generic (@2090751 @2093022)

@6909519 - Elen1020
this map is good except one point that this map cannot be no-balloon because in the antigravity version of this map a stable and practical foundation using a balloon can be made like http://i.imgur.com/OmijMcr.png
- possible solutions examples: make this map antigravity, make the wood ground thicker etc.

@6915285 - Makudomakudo
almost impossible to make a completely stable structure which is not affected much by mice's weight. this map gets significantly easier when the mice are pro and cooperative.

@6913878 - Elvaaaaa
withdrawn