Rotation Officielle - P4

#8715

Left as is:
@7185220 - Balvas - First of all, the clouds around the hole and cheese seems randomly placed; and the map is way too long for P4. I suggest you remove the clouds and send this map to P8.
@4399394 - Uuviinhasz - The map itself is using a lot of concepts at the same time (wind, dynamic ice, clouds). I suggest you to only use one of them so it can stay simple. Also, the left part of the map is soloable with the balls and the balloons, you could remove them.
@7009440 - Zeleny - I see that you have done a few edits to this map. The main problem is that the lengthy of the map fits better on a P8 category, and the clouds result slightly disappointing. I suggest you this: We could discuss this map in private and see how to improve it, so you can post another map in the thread.
@4948640 - Donmickey - The grounds seem randomly placed which turns it dull after a time. I recommend you start over with a new map!
@4009090 - Pamdecp - I understand you tried to create something new and interesting with this mechanism. But the map can be easily solved with a bridge and the whole build results very linear. P1 it's already fine.
@7180900 - V_21 - I understand that you tried to create a simple design with two different paths to offer some variety. But the build is too linear and the concept can't offer something new/fun to rotation.
@7126585 - Verdolagas - Entiendo que hayas intentado crear un mapa simple y agradable, pero faltan muchos detalles por pulir. 1) La nube que rodea al queso es innecesaria, Creo puedes hacer algo mejor. 2) Una vez que llegas a la parte izquierda del mapa es muy incómodo comenzar una base, necesitas agregar un apoyo para el chamán.
@7187760 - Currint - The map requires a lot of linear building which turns it slightly boring and repetitive. I think you should create another map which requires a shorter build. Also, remember that mice should work less than the shaman in a P4 category.
@7187761 - Squihd - The map can be easily solved with a single plank. I recommend you create something more challenging!
@4935178 - Pgmsule - The design and concept of your map is too simple, I recommend you start over with a new map that can be more challenging and exciting!
@7188532 - Gamog - I have seen others maps with the same design, I don't think this can offer something new/fun to rotation.
@7099098 - Pjfsamora - I think you are using a lot of grounds which makes it cramped and slightly frustrating. I suggest you remove some of them. Also, both paths to cheese are unbalanced (top is easier than the bottom).
@7171341 - Pashele - A primera vista el mapa se ve agradable, pero una vez que comienzas a construir el suelo se siente muy reducido, y las nubes lo vuelven un poco molesto. Te aconsejo hacer las nubes menos anchas y remover un suelo de hierba.
@7188801 - Elgordomesis - Wrong category.
@7189255 - Pnoynoy - Wrong category
@7140498 - Dmv - The map is too long and difficult for inexperienced players. I recommend you make it a LOT easier.
@7190498 - Yakitak - The design is too simple and the map can be easily solved with a single bridge+ramp. I recommend you create a new map that could be more challenging are exciting!
@7190710 - Reppam - The concept is friendly but we already have a few maps that offer the same build. I suggest you add a background to the map so I can P1 it.
@7191011 - Bendittt - The map is too long for P4, I recommend you make it shorter. Also, you need to improve the decoration!
@1972642 - Sekui - The map's design is too simple and half of the map has no use. Also, the extra gravity is not an exciting challenge. I recommend you start over with a new map.
@7191571 - Vlump - The map is too simple for P4. Try to make it more exciting.
@7165218 - Pingouuu - I understand you tried to create something friendly for inexperienced players, but the map offers a simple build we already have in some P4 maps.
@7191717 - Andrezitow - The map is too long for P4 and the build can't offer something new to rotation.
@7192105 - Junota - The map can be easily solved with a single bridge+ramp. And most of the players would ignore the right path of the map.
@4885091 - Hea - The map is too difficult and complicated for new players. They won't know how to correctly use both circles. Also, the build is too long.
@7192912 - Fuwb - Too simple for P4.
@7119857 - Momo9kiki - Wrong category.
@6425334 - Commandantso - Too simple for P4. I have seen a lot of maps that offer the same concept, so this can't offer something new to rotation.
@7194407 - Anabooleta - I will list my observations. 1) The cloud at the middle is a concept we already have in rotation, I recommend you try something new. 2) The gravity results more frustrating than challenging, I suggest you remove it.
@7190868 - Mousemalik - I have seen many other maps that offer the same concept. I don't think this can add something new/fun to rotation.
@7195146 - Bataatiinha - I enjoyed how you used the B planks. The map has potential for P4, so I will list my observations: 1) The map is too long, you could make it shorter and send it here again, or keep it and send it to P8. 2) The spaces are really cramped, for example the path to hole results really frustrating. 3) You could remove the roof, it intervenes a lot with the build.
@7181539 - Eyux - The map can be easily solved with a single ramp, and the right part has no use.
@7195400 - Papelio - El diseño puede parecer atractivo pero la jugabilidad del mapa aún puede mejorar. La construcción solo requiere de un puente hacía el queso y una tabla inclinada hacía el hoyo. Entiendo que colocaste nubes para que el chamán pueda elegir un camino distinto, pero la manera de resolverlo sigue siendo la misma.
@6912290 - Viniciusdara – I understand you tried to mix a few concepts to make it interesting but sadly the gameplay results more frustrating. Also a mouse without pair can’t complete the map as easily as the ones with pair.
@7195590 - Kokoeurospko - The map can be easily solved with a bridge.
@7194632 - Awesomehobo - We don't accept art maps in P4 category.
@7188204 - S4rg4sm - Too cramped.
@7190260 - Egecanege - The map can be easily solved with a single ramp, since the right part is soloable. Try to fix it.
@7190924 - Mivale – The left part of the map can be solved with a single bridge and the right part is soloable. I suggest you fix this.

P1'ed:
@7179197 - Neiiii - The design and the gameplay are fine, but it needs to be more challenging and exciting for P4. P1 will be ok!
@7188217 - V_Ntage - I liked the concept but the build is way too linear. P1 will be fine!
@7154981 - Tohpy - Cute simplicity. P1 will do it.
@7088544 - Yuugiooohhhh - Se aprecia el diseño, pero el mapa puede ser fácilmente resuelto con algunas tablas horizontales. P1 estará bien.
@7110496 - Framnm - P1 will be fine
@6316577 - Commupro – I liked the main concept but I don’t see farther than P1!
@7190395 - Satrianegara - Cute simplicity. P1!
@7132113 - Maxislow – El diseño es agradable, pero la construcción ofrece una jugabilidad muy parecida a otros mapas P4 en rotación. P1 será suficiente.
@7146001 - Mquk – I tested the map six times and the players always solved the top of the map, the bottom was slightly ignored. P1 will be ok!
@7178783 - Grimmaro – I loved the concept and the variety of solutions but tests showed it is too difficult for inexperienced players. Right now is P1 but I would like to discuss which edits can we implement to make it easier.

P4’ed:
@7183378 - Danielmago – P8’ed
@7191124 - Tennistete -

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue